How Do You Prevent Probate Being Granted in NSW?
)
How Do You Prevent Probate Being Granted in NSW?
When someone dies, an executor named in their Will can apply to the Supreme Court of NSW for a Grant of Probate. A grant of Probate formally recognises the executor's appointment under the Will and provides authority to administer the deceased estate.
However, what happens if you believe the Will is invalid, there are concerns about the circumstances in which it was made, or you believe someone else has a legitimate interest in the estate?
In certain circumstances, it is possible to take steps to prevent Probate from being granted while those concerns are investigated. One of the most important mechanisms is known as a Caveat Against a Grant of Probate.
What is a Probate Caveat?
A Probate Caveat is a formal notice lodged with the Supreme Court of NSW to prevent a Grant of Probate or Letters of Administration from being issued without prior notice to the person who lodged the caveat.
Its purpose is to preserve the position while a dispute concerning the estate is investigated or determined.
A caveat does not invalidate a Will, revoke an executor's appointment or establish that the person lodging it is entitled to inherit. Rather, it places a procedural obstacle in the way of obtaining a grant until the caveat is dealt with.
Who Can Lodge a Probate Caveat?
Generally, only a person with an interest in the deceased estate may have standing to lodge a caveat.
This may include:
A beneficiary named in an earlier Will who believes a later Will is invalid.
A person who would inherit under the intestacy provisions if the current Will were invalid.
An affected person who believes the deceased lacked testamentary capacity when making the Will.
An affected person who suspects the Will was procured through undue influence, fraud or other improper conduct.
An affected person who claims the Will is a forgery.
An affected person who disputes whether the document relied upon is the deceased's valid last Will.
It is important to establish that the person has a sufficient interest in the estate. Simply disagreeing with the deceased's testamentary wishes is not necessarily enough.
What Grounds Can Justify Preventing Probate?
There are several circumstances in which a person may have legitimate grounds to challenge a proposed Grant of Probate.
1. Lack of Testamentary Capacity
A Will may be challenged if the deceased lacked the necessary testamentary capacity when it was made.
The traditional test comes from Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549. The testator must understand:
The nature and effect of making a Will.
The general extent of their property.
The people who might reasonably be expected to benefit from their estate and be able to weigh up their competing claims.
That no disorder of the mind has influenced their testamentary dispositions.
Evidence of dementia, Alzheimer’s or other cognitive impairment does not automatically invalidate a Will. The question is whether the deceased had the required capacity when the Will was executed.
2. Undue Influence
A Will may be challenged where someone improperly coerced or influenced the deceased into making provisions that did not represent their genuine testamentary intentions.
Unlike some other legal relationships, undue influence in the context of a Will requires proof of actual coercion. Persuasion, pressure or involvement in preparing a Will is not normally sufficient.
3. Suspicious Circumstances and Lack of Knowledge and Approval
Concerns may arise where a beneficiary has been heavily involved in arranging the Will, particularly where that beneficiary receives a substantial benefit.
For example, circumstances may be suspicious where:
A beneficiary arranges the appointment with the solicitor.
The beneficiary provides the instructions for the Will.
The beneficiary is present throughout the entire Will-making process.
The Will substantially departs from previous testamentary arrangements without an apparent explanation.
The High Court decision in Barry v Butlin (1838) 2 Moo PC 480 establishes important principles concerning suspicious circumstances and the obligation to satisfy the Court that the Will represents the deceased's intentions.
The NSW Court of Appeal also considered suspicious circumstances in Mekail v Hana [2019] NSWCA 197.
Importantly, suspicious circumstances do not automatically invalidate a Will. They may, however, require the person propounding the Will to provide further evidence that the deceased knew and approved of its contents.
4. Failure to Comply with Formal Execution Requirements
A Will may also be challenged if it does not comply with the formal requirements under section 6 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).
Generally, a Will must be in writing, signed by the testator (or another person in the testator's presence and at their direction), and witnessed by two witnesses in accordance with the statutory requirements.
However, section 8 of the Act allows the Supreme Court to dispense with certain formal requirements where it is satisfied that a document expresses the deceased's testamentary intentions.
Therefore, a failure to comply with formal execution requirements does not necessarily mean that a document cannot be admitted to probate.
How Do You Lodge a Probate Caveat in NSW?
A caveat is lodged with the Probate Registry of the Supreme Court of NSW.
The person lodging the caveat should identify their interest in the estate and the basis upon which they object to a grant being issued.
The process generally involves:
Identifying the deceased and the relevant estate.
Establishing the person's interest in the estate.
Completing the prescribed Probate Caveat form.
Lodging the caveat with the Supreme Court of NSW and paying the applicable filing fee.
Serving or notifying relevant parties where required.
A caveat is generally effective for six months unless withdrawn, removed or extended in accordance with the applicable rules. The Court does not warn the party lodging the caveat before the six month period lapses and the lodging party must renew the caveat before it lapses or a person can apply for and obtain Probate without notice once a caveat has lapsed.
It is important to understand that a caveat is not a substitute for commencing substantive proceedings where a genuine dispute exists.
What Happens After a Caveat Is Lodged?
Once a caveat has been lodged, the Probate Registry will generally not issue a grant while the caveat remains effective.
The executor or another interested party may take steps to have the caveat removed or resolved.
Depending on the circumstances, this may involve:
The caveator withdrawing the caveat.
The executor issuing a warning requiring the caveator to enter an appearance.
The caveator entering an appearance to maintain the objection.
The parties resolving the dispute by agreement.
Court proceedings to determine the validity of the Will or the entitlement to a grant.
If the dispute cannot be resolved, the Supreme Court may need to determine whether the Will is valid and whether Probate should be granted.
Can You Lodge a Caveat Simply Because You Are Disappointed With Your Inheritance?
No. A Probate Caveat should not be used simply because someone is unhappy with the deceased's decision to leave their estate to another person.
For example, an adult child who has been excluded from a parent's Will may have a potential family provision claim under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).
However, a family provision claim and a challenge to the validity of a Will are different legal proceedings.
A family provision claim seeks an adequate provision from the estate. It does not necessarily challenge the validity of the Will or prevent Probate from being granted.
An adult child may therefore have a potential family provision claim without having sufficient grounds to lodge a Probate Caveat.
What Should You Do If You Have Concerns About a Will?
If you believe a deceased person's Will is invalid, or you have concerns about the circumstances in which it was prepared, it is important to obtain legal advice promptly.
Evidence should be preserved, including:
Previous Wills and any testamentary documents.
Medical records and evidence of the deceased's cognitive condition.
Solicitors' attendance notes and file records.
Correspondence concerning the preparation of the Will.
Evidence of the deceased's relationship with beneficiaries.
Evidence of any statements made by the deceased about their testamentary intentions.
Information about the involvement of beneficiaries in preparing or executing the Will.
A properly considered caveat may provide valuable protection while a dispute is investigated. However, lodging a caveat without proper grounds may expose the caveator to legal costs and other consequences.
Conclusion
A Probate Caveat can be an important legal mechanism for preventing a Grant of Probate from being issued while a genuine dispute concerning a deceased person's Will is investigated.
Whether a caveat is appropriate will depend on the person's interest in the estate, the evidence available and the nature of the objection.
If you have concerns about the validity of a Will or believe that Probate should not be granted, obtaining advice early can help protect your legal interests and avoid unnecessary estate litigation.
Contact us for a free thirty-minute consultation with an estate planning lawyer.
Any information on this website is general in nature and should not be taken as personal legal advice. We recommend that you speak to a lawyer about your personal circumstances.
Photo by Jakub Żerdzicki on Unsplash
| Tags:Legal ChallengesFamily LawProbateFamily Provision Claim |
